しかし、Amazon のキラー機能である Alexa 音声アクティベーションについて説明しましょう。 AirPods Pro の「Hey Siri」機能と同じくらい優れており、「Alexa」と話しかけて音声コマンドでフォローすることで AI ボットを起動できます。これにより、無数のアレクサスキルへの扉が開かれます。 Google Assistant または Siri をデフォルトの音声アシスタントとして選択できるため、Amazon はどちらも区別しません。
Samsung は引き続きユーザーに Bixby 音声アシスタントをプッシュしていますが、「Hi Bixby」音声コマンドを登録できないという問題があります。 Galaxy Buds Pro では音声認識がわずかに優れており、マイクがボーカルをより正確に拾います。 Siri と Google Assistant も buds と互換性があります。
受賞者： Amazon Echo Buds 2
Amazon Echo Buds 2 vs. Samsung Galaxy Buds Pro: 音質
(Image credit: Regan Coule/Future)
The Galaxy Buds Pro is one of the best-sounding pairs of wireless earbuds that money can buy, and sounds even better with the Galaxy S21 lineup. Large two-way speakers are housed underneath the hood to deliver deep bass and rich mids. The company’s proprietary Scalable Codec gives these buds a hi-res boost when paired with one of the newer Galaxy smartphones, and the results are remarkable. Using another Android device or iPhone does bring down the quality, though you’ll still enjoy energetic sound despite the minimal loss in audio.
Samsung also developed a special sound mode, called 360 Audio, that employs Dolby Head Tracking to create “multi-dimensional sound” and achieve greater audio depth when watching videos. It’s not as convincing or immersive as Apple’s spatial audio mode, but there is opportunity for Samsung to build on the feature and make it essential for future releases in the Galaxy Buds series.
(Im age credit: Regan Coule/Future)
The Echo Buds 2 sounds better than the original. Amazon took the liberty of increasing both the low end and treble, giving their neutral sound profile more oomph. Tracks with prominent basslines are well represented and have a warm, impactful presence, while instrumental-heavy recordings are reproduced well; musicians and band members receive individual shine.
Amazon’s buds don’t come with any extra audio features, nor do they have the sonic prowess to compete with other elite-sounding models. They will suffice for casual listening on commutes or around the house. Just don’t expect sound quality to blow you away.
Winner: Samsung Galaxy Buds Pro
Amazon Echo Buds 2 vs. Samsung Galaxy Buds Pro: Active noise cancellation
(Image credit: Regan Coule/Tom’s Guide)
We prefer the Echo Buds 2’s ANC based on the level of ambient noise it can handle and wind resistance. Amazon’s three-mic array puts a kibosh on indoor distractions like household appliances and guests. It also performs well in retail establishments like coffee shops and pharmacies; silencing the humming noises produced by the CVS refrigerators was gratifying. When outside, the technology minimized loud noises like car horns and construction tools. Wind didn’t bother us much either when listening to music in drafty conditions.
PassThrough is Amazon’s version of ambient sound mode and it’s useful for gaining better awareness of your surroundings. You can communicate clearly with baristas and eavesdrop on conversations, plus the feature can be adjusted to increase or decrease the amount of noise you want the mics to pick up. Max level will make external sounds more distinguishable without being too harsh on your ears.
(Image credit: Regan Coule/Future)
The Galaxy Buds Pro claims to have with the “most intelligent ANC capabilities of any true wireless earbuds” and can supposedly reduce 99% of backgr ound noise. That is so far from the truth. At best, these buds will mute rowdy family members or a loud television playing the background, but don’t expect it to do the same with crying babies or a whistling tea kettle. Samsung’s proprietary Wind Shield technology performs badly in gusty climates as well.
Samsung’s Transparency Mode, conversely, is more powerful than Amazon’s PassThrough and superb for honing in on certain sounds in your vicinity. You can adjust the amount of noise you want to let in by selecting from four different levels, though you’ll want to go no further than the third level to protect your hearing.
A Voice Detect feature was also developed that works conjointly with ambient listening by decreasing playback volume and increasing audio passthrough volume, so you can clearly speak with others without removing the buds. Still, on ANC effectiveness, this one goes to Amazon.
Winner: Amazon Echo Buds 2
Amazon Echo Buds 2 vs. Samsung Galaxy Buds Pro: Special features and apps
(Image credit: Regan Coule/Future)
Despite the Echo Buds 2 having a broader feature set, the Galaxy Buds Pro counters with its own innovative features to even the functionality odds.
The Alexa app doesn’t just provide different ways to personalize the Echo Buds 2, but also grants access to anything Amazon related. Entering the Settings page will show you toggle controls for the listening modes, battery life, and Alexa, along with a customization field that expands on features. These include control customization, an EQ to adjust different sound elements (e.g., bass, mid-range, treble), and the Ear Fit Tip Test.
There’s also a Workout mode that transforms the buds into a fitness tracker to record your fitness performance; the AirPods Pro 2 is rumored to get something similar, so the Echo Buds 2 could be a trendsetter here. Don’t think of it as a replacement for your Fitbit or Apple Watch, though, but more as a “damn-my-tracker-just-died-and-I-need-a-backup” solution.
What gives the Echo Buds 2 such mass appeal is its phenomenal Alexa integration. You want to assign a default music service, handle productivity tasks, shop online, control all Echo Products or manage other compatible devices? The Echo Buds 2 makes all of this a reality and does it flawlessly.
(Image credit: Regan Coule/Tom’s Guide)
The Galaxy Buds Pro has its own set of personalization perks in the Galaxy Wearable app. Users can customize the controls, tweak sound, cycle through the different levels of each listening mode, and find other goodies that are unavailable on other wireless earbuds. The built-in EQ has six presets that complement different music genres, plus there is the aforementioned 360 Audio and Scalable Codec features to enhance audio output. A recent firmware update also added a sound adjustment setting to aid listeners with hearing impairments by tweaking the balance of sound on the left and right earbuds.
Then come the features that are exclusive to compatible Samsung Galaxy smartphones. First is SmartThings Find, a service available through the SmartThings app showing the GPS location of any lost or stolen earbuds. Gaming Mode can be selected in the Labs setting and decreases audio lag when gaming on Galaxy devices. And of course, there is PowerShare to wirelessly charge the buds by placing the charging case on the back of a Galaxy smartphone.
Connectivity is stable on these two products, giving you up to 35 feet of wireless listening. The Echo Buds makes pairing more seamless with a button on the case that expedites the process when Bluetooth acts up. Multipoint technology is missing on both devices, but the Galaxy Buds Pro has an Auto Switch mode that will instantly pair the buds to a secondary device after unpairing from your primary device.
They’re equally good for video chats. However, the Echo Buds 2 gives you acceptable calling performance and has a Sidetone to make your voice sound louder and clearer. Amazon’s noise-cancelling technology will also keep background noises to a minimum.
(Image credit: Regan Coule/Future)
The Galaxy Buds Pro comes in handy when you want to join in on Zoom or Skype calls, but it disappoints when used as a calling headset. Samsung’s mic array and new Voice Pickup Unit (VPU) struggle to pick up vocals in loud environments.
Winner: Amazon Echo Buds 2
Amazon Echo Buds 2 vs. Samsung Galaxy Buds Pro: Battery life
(Image credit: Regan Coule/Tom’s Guide)
Amazon and Samsung both rate battery life at 5 hours with ANC on. That’s only 30 minutes longer than the AirPods Pro (4.5 hours) and is still considered some of the weakest in the category. Bear in mind too that volume, streaming, and special features will decrease playtime by about an hour or so. That leaves us to discuss extended listening times when ANC is turned off. The Galaxy Buds Pro has more in the tank with 8 hours when ANC and Bixby are turned off; the Echo Buds does 6.5 hours with ANC and Alexa disabled.
(Image credit: Tom’s Guide)
Samsung has the more generous charging case as well, providing between 18 hours (ANC on) and 28 hours (ANC off) when fully charged. Amazon’s charging case underwhelms with a full charge holding between 15 hours (ANC on) and 19.5 hours (ANC off).
Quick charging is identical with a 15-minute charge netting you 2 hours of use on either pair of buds.
Again, wireless charging cases are available for both models. The only difference is that Samsung includes it with the Galaxy Buds Pro as standard, whereas Amazon wants an extra $20 for it.
Winner: Samsung Galaxy Buds Pro
Amazon Echo Buds 2 vs. Samsung Galaxy Buds Pro: Verdict
Despite losing more categories, the Galaxy Buds Pro performs better in most of the major ones, while falling not too far behind in the ones it lost. Audio is some of the finest you’ll hear in the category and Samsung’s exclusive features are intriguing enough to make you consider owning a new Galaxy smartphone, though you’ll still get some great performance on an iPhone or any other Android device.
Call quality isn’t great, and Samsung’s ecosystem won’t be for everyone (you’ll probably opt out of using Bixby). Still, for most users it will be a lot easier to live with these drawbacks than, say, inferior sound quality or poor battery life.
<表>
Amazon Echo Buds 2
Samsung Galaxy Buds Pro
Price and value (5)
5
4
Design (15)
11
13
Controls (10)
8
7
Audio quality (20)
15
18
Active noise cancellation(20)
15
14
Special features and apps (15)
13
13
Call quality (5)
3
2
Battery life (10)
6
7
Total score (100)
76
78
The Echo Buds 2 is a noteworthy update that improves on noise cancellation and sound quality. Giving owners the full-on Alexa experience directly through the buds is also quite the feat, especially when taking into account the lower launch price. The smaller design is another positive that shouldn’t be overlooked. There is much value to be gained from this second-gen version, but we feel the Galaxy Buds Pro has more going for it, even if it costs a few more dollars to enjoy.
